Introduction: Stop Letting Good Leads Vanish Like an Unserved Summons
You know that frustrating moment when you’re trying to serve a defendant, but they keep dodging you? One day they’re at home, the next they’re "on vacation", and suddenly, their entire life is a series of strategic grocery store runs at 2 AM just to avoid signing that piece of paper.
That’s exactly what happens with your website visitors when you don’t have a retargeting strategy in place.
They visit your law firm’s website. They click around, maybe even land on your “Schedule a Consultation” page. But then they leave—without filling out the form, without calling, and without giving you a single chance to close the deal.
Are they gone forever? Not if you retarget them.
Retargeting ads allow your firm to follow those lost visitors around the internet, gently (or aggressively) reminding them that they still need legal help. Think of it as a digital process server, making sure your firm stays top-of-mind until they finally pick up the phone and book a consultation.
In this guide, we’ll break down how retargeting works for law firms, why it’s a game-changer, and how to use it to turn more website visitors into actual clients.
What Is Retargeting and Why Should Law Firms Care?
The Problem: 97% of Visitors Leave Without Contacting You
Most law firms assume that if someone visits their website and doesn’t immediately call, they’re not interested. That’s dead wrong.
Here’s the reality:✅ Over 97% of website visitors don’t convert on their first visit.✅ Many of them are seriously considering hiring a lawyer—but they’re still researching.✅ If you don’t remind them about your firm, they’ll probably hire your competitor instead.
The Solution: Retargeting Ads
Retargeting (also called remarketing) allows you to show ads specifically to people who have visited your website but didn’t take action. These ads appear when they:✔ Scroll through Facebook, Instagram, or LinkedIn.✔ Browse news sites like CNN or Forbes.✔ Watch YouTube videos or check their Gmail inbox.
Retargeting helps re-engage visitors and keep your law firm top-of-mind—until they’re ready to take action.
How Retargeting Works (A Simple Breakdown)
Someone visits your website (e.g., “DUI Lawyer in Miami”).
A tracking pixel (from Google Ads or Facebook) tags them.
They leave without calling or filling out a form.
Your ads start following them on social media, news sites, and YouTube.
After seeing your ad a few times, they remember you and come back to book a consultation.
It’s digital persistence, but without the creepy van parked outside their house.
Where Can Law Firms Run Retargeting Ads?
Google Display Network (GDN)
Shows banner ads on millions of websites (news, blogs, forums, etc.).
Can retarget based on specific pages visited (e.g., only targeting people who checked your “DUI Defense” page).
YouTube Retargeting
Shows video ads before YouTube videos.
Example: A user searches “What to do after a car accident”, visits your site, leaves, and then sees your law firm’s YouTube ad later.
Facebook & Instagram Retargeting
Retargets users with scroll-stopping image or video ads.
Can target visitors based on practice area (e.g., show divorce ads only to people who visited your “Family Law” page).
LinkedIn Retargeting
More expensive, but great for targeting business owners or high-net-worth individuals (estate planning, corporate law, etc.).
Gmail & Search Retargeting
Show ads in Gmail inboxes of people who visited your website.
Retarget users when they search related legal terms later.
Best Strategy? Run retargeting across multiple platforms to maximize visibility.
How Law Firms Should Segment Their Retargeting Ads
Not all website visitors are the same. Someone looking for a personal injury lawyer has different needs than someone looking for a divorce attorney.
Here’s how to segment your retargeting for higher conversions:
1. By Practice Area
Visitors who checked your DUI page? Show them DUI-related ads.
Estate planning visitors? Show them trust and will-related ads.
Divorce clients? Show them ads about child custody, alimony, and property division.
2. By Engagement Level
Someone who visited three pages and stayed for five minutes? They’re highly interested—target them aggressively.
Someone who bounced in 10 seconds? Lower priority—maybe retarget them with an informational blog post instead of a hard sell.
3. By Stage of Intent
Just browsing? Serve ads that build trust (testimonials, client reviews, “Why Choose Us?”).
Ready to hire? Show urgency-focused ads (e.g., “Get Legal Help Today” with a strong CTA).
How to Write Killer Retargeting Ads That Actually Convert
If your ads are boring, nobody clicks them. Here’s how to make them irresistible.
1. Call Out Their Problem (Fast)
Your ad should make it immediately clear that you know their situation.
❌ Bad: “Miami’s Best Personal Injury Lawyer”
✅ Good: “Injured in an Accident? You May Be Entitled to Compensation.”
❌ Bad: “We Handle Divorce Cases”
✅ Good: “Protect Your Kids and Assets—Get the Divorce Representation You Deserve.”
2. Use Urgency & Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)
Many people put off hiring a lawyer. Create urgency.
✔ “Time is Running Out to File Your Claim—Talk to an Attorney Now.”✔ “You Only Get One Shot at a Strong Defense—Make It Count.”
3. Use Client Reviews & Social Proof
People trust other people more than they trust ads. Use client testimonials in your retargeting.
✔ “5-Star Rated Family Law Firm—See What Our Clients Say.”✔ “$10M+ Won for Injury Victims—Get a Free Case Review.”
How to Avoid Wasting Money on Retargeting Ads
🚨 Mistake 1: Retargeting Everyone (Even Junk Traffic)Use Google Analytics and Meta Pixel to exclude:
❌ People who bounced after 5 seconds.
❌ Visitors from irrelevant locations.
❌ Existing clients (no need to waste money on them).
🚨 Mistake 2: Annoying People with Too Many AdsCap ad frequency at 5-7 impressions per week. Nobody likes being followed too aggressively.
🚨 Mistake 3: Not Tracking ConversionsIf you don’t track which retargeting ads actually turn into leads, you’ll waste money fast. Use Google Tag Manager and Facebook Pixel for proper tracking.
Final Verdict: Retargeting = More Clients, Less Waste
If you’re not using retargeting, you’re letting 97% of your website visitors walk away forever.
By implementing smart retargeting ads, your firm can:✔ Stay top-of-mind until leads are ready to hire you.✔ Show the right ads to the right people at the right time.✔ Turn lost visitors into paying clients—without increasing your ad budget.
If you’re ready to stop losing leads and start dominating your local market, we can help. Let’s talk.
Comments